68 to 70 by day, a bit lower at night, is the range that works here
That's the number. A setback schedule your furnace can actually recover from, checked by a professional before the cold sets in, is what makes that range hold through a Wisconsin winter instead of just looking good on paper.
You could spend an afternoon calling around, explaining the same furnace and the same setback schedule to three different companies, then sorting through what each one quotes you. Or you could answer a few questions about your house and let a contractor who already works on furnaces like yours reach out to you directly. You know what temperature to set. What's left is making sure the equipment behind that number is ready for the season asking the most of it.
